Book Review: Pose Wobble Flow

By Haley Master

Why a Second Edition?:

In September of 2015, Antero Garcia and Cindy O’Donnell-Allen released the first edition of Pose, Wobble, and Flow, providing a fresh liberatory framework for deconstructing the idea that there is a “best” way to teach. They concluded that first edition by stating “By various measures, we are in a cultural, social crisis today. Radical persecution, the stratification and thinning of the middle class, and salient examples of violence- symbolic and physical- toward nonheterosexual or transgender members of society run rampant today. This is not a hyperbole” (2015, p. 133). They then open this second edition affirming “We take no joy in the accuracy of these predictions, but we could not have imagined the breathtaking scale, scope, and speed with which the social, cultural, and global fabric of the world would unravel” (2026, p. 2).  Garcia and O’Donnell’s methods and pedagogy around teaching are not only, and unfortunately, extremely relevant, but more important than ever. This second edition further expands on the significance and impact it has to ensure that children and young adults from all backgrounds have the same opportunities for success and that educators, parents, and administrators feel empowered by the work they’re doing rather than dehumanized.

Overview:

Adapting the pose, wobble, and flow method of yoga as a pedagogical model, they encourage readers to move through the challenges of teaching rather than striving for impossible perfection. The book presents six different “poses” of teaching in order to guide teachers through the numerous challenges that teachers face in this current climate as well as presenting ways to promote equity, social change, and vulnerable learning. What it means to pose in teaching is to take up a “liberatory stance” toward your practice (Garcia and O’Donnell, 2024, p.7). Garcia and O’Donnell make it very clear that this is not a “foolproof” method to teaching, but rather “touchstones” as a way to guide teachers through different settings (Garcia and O’Donnell, 2024, p.8). The book introduces the idea of wobbling when Teachers will always be presented with unexpected challenges and complex situations that will test their limits and push them into an area of uncomfortability. Garcia and O’Donnell argue that this push is not meant to be a breaking point, but rather a point of transition. That transition and nonlinear process is how teachers strengthen their practice and learn how to move through dynamic circumstances. Garcia and O’Donnell refer to “flow” as “the moments of psychological well-being one experiences in singular moments during the everyday course of teaching”  as well as “the complementary poses together over the span of one’s teaching career” (Garcia and O’Donnell, 2024, p.10). They maintain that the ambiguity of teaching can make it difficult to feel as though you are hitting goals or climbing new peaks in your career. The objective of the “flow” phase as a teacher is to enter a flow state that incorporates both different poses as well as wobbling to be constantly growing as an educator.

Key Takeaways:

Garcia and O’Donnell set the foundation for the book with their pose of “teaching for liberation” which is recognizing the inequities, identities, and backgrounds of different students as a way to not only be an active advocate for social change, but to encourage students to recognize those nuances as well. Rather than striving for perfection, they foster the idea that a liberatory pedagogy is a “process of becoming” that requires necessary transformation  in order to move through the challenges that educators will inevitably face. While this may seem like a daunting task, they urge for small but meaningful moments that will work towards a collective shift in the way institutions and classrooms operate. They then highlight the importance of being a “vulnerable learner” which can help “retain a sense of agency in your work and, even on darker days, can consistently infuse it with meaning” (Garcia and O’Donnell, 2024, p.37). The significance of this pose is to encourage teachers to see themselves and their students as continual learners rather than a part of a larger systemic machine. Instead of referring to the individual experience of vulnerability, Garcia and O’Donnell also emphasize that a lot of the challenges that students face are a part of a collective problem that requires vulnerability in order to broach and change. Garcia and O’Donnell’s third pose is a push for literacy for civic engagement and how teachers can both acknowledge the different civic identities of students in their classroom, but also how to purposefully tie those identities into literacy activities and classroom practices. Even though conversations about systemic issues with students can be difficult, it does not go away by choosing to not address them in the classroom. In addition, the ways that active practices around civics will transform students’ and teachers’ lives inside and outside of the classroom are the heart of why this field is so important. 

Pedagogical Tools:

Garcia and O’Donnell added the pose of developing an identity as a writer who teaches as well as a teacher who writes because it “maximizes the learning outcomes of your students” and can be “central to your own professional growth” (Garcia and O’Donnell, 2024, p.98). The value of this pose is so that teachers can both be frequently involved in the practice of writing in a similar way to their students and to the practice of writing instruction. The underline the importance of writing has specifically to BIPOC students and their identity given that it has historically not been something that education systems have encouraged. The act of writing itself is an act of civic engagement. Along with writing, reading and literacy plays a substantial role in what students learn and how they perceive the world. The curation of texts that schools develop and the ways that teachers must wobble around ones that are less accessible for students are essential to nurturing a lifelong passion for reading and literature. An interesting point that they raise is the responsibility teachers have to “help students understand their agency as readers” and to “shift stances and practices based on the texts they encounter” (Garcia and O’Donnell, 2024, p. 128). Teaching and engaging with texts is not a black and white process, but rather a fluid method of meeting students where they are as readers and incorporating recommendations that will expand their horizons and connect with them.

Recommendation:

This book is essential for not only educators, but for parents, administration, caregivers, and leaders who aspire to cultivate a learning environment that encourages and inspires students well after their time spent in the classroom. It breaks down the idea that a teacher is someone with all of the knowledge and students are simply there to absorb what a teacher says. Garcia and O’Donnell approach learning as a nuanced and complex system of shared information where both students and teachers are constantly learning and improving in order to enact change and work towards a better tomorrow. 

Pose, Wobble, and Flow: A Culturally Proactive Approach to Literary Instruction, Antero Garcia and Cindy O’Donnell Allen, Teachers College Press, Second Edition, 2024, #6.95, ISBN: 9780807769348

Bio: Haley Master is a West Chester University English M.A student as well as a sales associate for Schiffer Publishing.